NCLAT HOLDS THAT A PLEA OF LIMITED GUARANTEE CANNOT OVERRIDE A CRYSTALLISED DEBT AND UPHOLDS REJECTION OF REPAYMENT PLANS OF PERSONAL GUARANTORS
The Hon’ble NCLAT, in its judgment dated September 21, 2026, in Bhumika Nilay R. Shah v. Prawincharan Prafulcharan Dwary & Ors., addressed the critical issue of whether the liability of personal guarantors of M/s Archon Engicon Ltd. was limited to the market value of their mortgaged properties under the Deed of Guarantee.
The appeals before the NCLAT arose from the order of the Ld. NCLT, Ahmedabad Bench, which allowed the applications filed by the Resolution Professional (RP) under Section 114 of the IBC seeking discharge, after the repayment plans of the personal guarantors were rejected by the Committee of Creditors (CoC), and held that the liability of the guarantors was not limited.
The Appellants contended that the Deed of Guarantee, read with the arrangement letter, the inter-creditor agreement, the sanction letters and the transaction audit report, restricted their liability to the market value of the mortgaged properties, and that the impugned order wrongly made them personally liable for the entire dues of the borrower.
The Respondent bank, on the other hand, contended that the extent of guarantee was to be examined at the time of finalization of the repayment plan, and that the DRT had already crystallized the dues.
The Hon’ble NCLAT, while dismissing the appeals, held as follows:
- Upon harmonious construction, the relevant clause in Deed of Guarantee pertains to the security arrangement and does not restrict the primary contractual liability other clauses, which impose liability for the principal sum with interest, costs and charges.
- The liability of the Appellants had already been adjudicated by the DRT by its order dated August 3, 2021, holding the guarantors jointly and severally liable for the entire dues. As this order attained finality and was never challenged, the extent of liability cannot be re-agitated in collateral proceedings under Section 114 of the IBC.
- The repayment plans failed to secure the requisite 66% voting share and were rejected, and Section 114 of the IBC does not confer jurisdiction upon the Adjudicating Authority to substitute its own commercial view where the statutory majority has not been achieved.
Conclusion:
The ruling seems to reinforce the binding nature of the decision of the CoC on repayment plans and the finality of DRT adjudications in individual insolvency proceedings. Furthermore, it underlines the importance of timely challenges to recovery orders and admitted claims, failing which guarantors may be precluded from contesting the extent of their liability at a later stage.
Published On:
- October 21, 2026
Contributors:
- Abhishek Swaroop
- Shreya Chandhok
- Rounak Doshi
- Bharath Krishna