IBBI ISSUES DISCUSSION PAPER ON STRENGTHENING SAFEGUARDS IN THE INSOLVENCY RESOLUTION PROCESS FOR PERSONAL GUARANTORS: RELATED PARTY VOTING, AVOIDANCE TRANSACTIONS, VALUATION AND REASONED CREDITOR DECISIONS
The insolvency framework applicable to personal guarantors under Chapter III of Part III of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Code) has evolved significantly in recent years. However, IBBI has observed that several creditor protection mechanisms available in corporate insolvency resolution processes do not currently exist in the resolution process of personal guarantors. To address these gaps, the Board has proposed four targeted reforms aimed at strengthening transparency, accountability and informed decision-making.
- Exclusion of Related Parties from Voting on the Repayment Plan: Under CIRP, a “related party” of the corporate debtor has no right to vote in the committee of creditors, while in the insolvency resolution process of a personal guarantor, only an “associate” of the guarantor is barred from voting. However, the definition of “associate” is much narrower than that of “related party”. For instance, a company that habitually acts on the guarantor’s advice or instructions, without the guarantor holding shares in it or controlling its board, would qualify as a related party but fall outside the definition of “associate”.
IBBI has highlighted that a related party may consequently vote on a repayment plan that itself determines the extent to which the guarantor is discharged from his debts. The concern that a party connected to the debtor should not influence a vote from which its connected debtor stands to benefit applies equally in both contexts.
Relying on section 109(2) of the Code, which provides that the voting share of each creditor shall be determined in the manner specified by the Board, read with section 240(2)(zq), IBBI has proposed a proviso to regulation 11(2) of the IRP Regulations assigning a “Nil” voting share to a creditor who is a related party of the guarantor as defined in section 5(24A) of the Code. Regulation 9(1) is also proposed to be amended to require the resolution professional to indicate separately, against each creditor in the list of creditors, whether such creditor is a related party of the guarantor.
- Identification and Reporting of Avoidance Transactions: Sections 164, 165 and 167 of the Code enable a bankruptcy trustee to apply to the Adjudicating Authority in respect of undervalued transactions, preference transactions and extortionate credit transactions entered into by a bankrupt within specified look-back periods, and section 164A empowers the Adjudicating Authority to reverse an undervalued transaction deliberately entered into to defraud creditors. However, during the insolvency resolution process that precedes bankruptcy, when the repayment plan is formulated and put to vote, the resolution professional is under no corresponding obligation to examine such transactions. By contrast, under the CIRP Regulations, the resolution professional must place details of preferential, undervalued, extortionate credit and fraudulent transactions (sections 43, 45, 50 and 66) before the committee of creditors along with the resolution plan.
IBBI has noted that the existence of such transactions bears directly on the value actually available to creditors and on whether the guarantor has made full and honest disclosure of his affairs, and that the risk of value erosion shortly before insolvency is no different merely because the debtor is an individual.
Accordingly, IBBI has proposed a new regulation 10A in the IRP Regulations requiring the resolution professional to examine and record whether the guarantor has been a party to a transaction referred to in sections 164, 164A, 165 or 167 of the Code, and to place his findings, along with supporting particulars, before the meeting of creditors. For this purpose, references in those sections to bankruptcy and the bankruptcy commencement date would be read as references to the resolution process and the resolution process commencement date. The resolution professional would also be able to take such action in respect of an identified transaction as he would have been entitled to take had a bankruptcy order been passed, thereby bringing this power forward to a stage where it can still meaningfully affect the value available under the repayment plan. The proposed solution contemplates such action being taken with the approval of the creditors.
- Valuation of Assets of the Personal Guarantor: The IRP Regulations do not presently provide for valuation of the assets of the personal guarantor, although valuation is contemplated under the frameworks applicable to CIRP, liquidation and the bankruptcy process for personal guarantors. IBBI has noted that, in the absence of an independent valuation, creditors may lack an objective basis to assess the adequacy of the security offered, the reasonableness of the repayment proposed, or the recovery alternatively available in a bankruptcy process.
To address this gap, IBBI has proposed a new regulation 10B requiring the resolution professional to appoint a registered valuer to determine the fair value and the realisable value of the guarantor’s assets, in accordance with valuation standards notified by the Board through circular. The valuer would submit the values along with a valuation report within the time specified by the resolution professional, and in any event before the repayment plan is placed before the meeting of creditors under regulation 17A. The fair value, realisable value and valuation report would be placed before that meeting, providing an objective basis for evaluating the repayment plan.
- Recording of Creditors’ Deliberations on the Repayment Plan: Under regulation 15 of the IRP Regulations, the minutes of the meeting of creditors record the names of creditors who voted for, against or abstained on the repayment plan, but there is no requirement to record the creditors’ own assessment of whether the plan is feasible and viable, or, where it offers very limited recovery, why it is nonetheless preferable to a bankruptcy process. Such a requirement exists for resolution plans under regulation 39(3)(b) of the CIRP Regulations.
IBBI has proposed a new sub-regulation (2A) in regulation 15 requiring the resolution professional to record in the minutes the deliberations of the creditors and the reasons for their decision, having regard, among other things, to the amount of admitted claims and the amount proposed to be paid, the duration and certainty of payments, the assets and liabilities of the guarantor including the fair and realisable value of his assets, his income and future repayment capacity, any transaction or conduct bearing on recovery (including transactions identified under regulation 10A), and the feasibility and viability of the repayment plan. Where the amount proposed to be paid is significantly lower than the admitted claims or the estimated realisable value of the guarantor’s assets, the resolution professional would be required to specifically record the creditors’ reasons for considering the repayment plan preferable to a bankruptcy process.
Conclusion:
The discussion paper reflects IBBI’s broader effort to strengthen creditor protection and improve decision-making standards in personal guarantor insolvency proceedings. By introducing restrictions on related-party voting, enabling early scrutiny of avoidance transactions, mandating asset valuation and requiring reasoned creditor deliberations, the proposed framework seeks to enhance transparency, fairness and commercial accountability in repayment plan approvals. Collectively, the proposals aim to align the insolvency resolution process for personal guarantors more closely with the safeguards already embedded within the corporate insolvency regime.
Published On:
- October 21, 2026
Contributors:
- Abhishek Swaroop
- Shreya Chandhok
- Rounak Doshi
- Bharath Krishna